Jagdpanther vs SU Eastern Front Duel Author: David R. Higgins; Illustrator: Richard Chasemore; Short code: DUE Jagdpanther vs SU Author: David R. Higgins ISBN: 1 6. Contributor: Andrew Nguyen Review Date: 17 Sep As with all German. However, from page 33 until the end of the book, we leave the discussion specifically of the Jagdpanther and SU, and launch into a military.
|Published (Last):||3 January 2012|
|PDF File Size:||7.68 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||8.76 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Soviet armoured fighting vehicles of World War II. Other books in the series.
In game, I give the edge to the jagdpanther for gun depression jagdlanther rate of fire. Matthew J35U5 1 Posted 03 November – Still haven’t received one real life opinion. MegaB0B0 2 Posted 04 November – This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Its sloped armor and relatively light weight meant, unlike the more massive and less practical Jagdtiger a Tiger II derivativeit could also operate in a more mobile capacity.
Frontally the Jagdpanther has the edge, but not by a significant amount. SU vs Jagdpanther 27 members have cast votes You have to complete 5 battles in order to participate this poll. Glad you enjoyed the SU in-game though, I found it pretty fun as well. Major Fulcrum 12 Posted 20 November – Force Developments in the Maghreb.
Gregg Brewer rated it liked it Mar 27, I just ordered this book a couple days ago, and va waiting for it’s arrival. In my opinion the mm DS and 8,8cm Pak 43 guns are near identical in performance, and there is nothing to suggest one is better jsgdpanther the other.
It is sy that German va had as much as twice the strength to thickness as allied armour, including the Russians. I’d lean a bit towards the JP at this point even though the D became the superior gun in the long run, being in my 3 most effective tank guns jagdppanther 1st being the DT because its caliber became the standard everyone bases themselves on nowadays.
Although its speed jagdpantther armour protection were comparable, the greater numbers fielded late in the war often proved decisive against an adversary increasingly forced to fight despite inadequate logistics and training. Expensive and hard to upgrade with larger armament owing to the constraints imposed by turret-ring size and suspension, turreted tanks gave way in some contexts to new designs. Funny that I just now saw this thread. I said not including reliability.
Mass production began in September Plus Russian doctrine called for closing to as close to the enemy as possible. Same goes for you. The Soviet testers were surprised jagdpanhher this as they expected a 30 mm plate to withstand a 45 mm shell at such a low impact velocity, so they had a local factory build them an identical test plate.
The SU is the better of the two for it’s ability to operate in all environments and weather, and it’s operational range. Leave this field blank: Liu Songyan rated it it was amazing Oct 08, Community Forum Software by IP.
SU-100 vs Jagdpanther
They tested a 30 mm thick section of its armour by firing a 45 mm shell at it. Unfortunately though, English books specifically about the SU seem to be essentially nonexistent, and I have been limited in my ability to research this tank.
Archived from the original PDF on 10 March But yeah, the D’s pen 1000 good. The majority aren’t even of Jagdpanthers and SU’s. While both guns have virtually the same performance, the German gun will get the edge because of the weight of the shells.
SU Vs. Jagdpanther – Historical Discussion – War Thunder – Official Forum
The various ammunition used for the Pak 43 guns was around 10kg or 11kg, where as the DS used ammunition in the 16kg range. Martin Landry rated it liked it Aug 06, I don’t really look at which board the treads I comment on are Not sure that’s the best way to do it. So which do you guys think was better? Ultimately the Jagdpanther is the better of the two in all-around mobility.
Mud getting stuck in it would be painful. I love tank destroyers, and love these two most of all. The combat performance looks to be the same for either vehicle, effective range is the same, accuracy is the same, armour jagdpatnher is the 1000, etc.
Want to Read Currently Reading Read. Gorlitskiychief designer of all medium Soviet self-propelled guns.
Many are of only average reproductive quality, and almost all are very small in size. Relative to the other nations, they were at least equal to the tank destroyers and assault guns fielded by the other nations, and enjoyed considerable success due to the eventual nature of the war Germany would find themselves in throughout much of WWII; defense.
Duel 1 – 10 of 86 books. In Aprila SU self-propelled gun was photographed being used in Yemen as part of the ongoing conflict. But whatever, fair enough.